Should I Attend a Funeral for a Nonbeliever?

Graveside funeral and casket.

Should a Christian go to a funeral for an unbeliever? What should we think about celebration of life services compared to traditional funerals? Is this like going to a same-sex wedding? Am I supporting something that I shouldn’t be supporting, or is this an opportunity for me to display my faith? How should we think of funerals for nonbelievers? That’s the topic of this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted. Subscribe and listen to Salty Believer Unscripted wherever you get your podcasts or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Funerals for Nonbelievers

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Good Pods | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | Podchaser | Listen Notes | YouTube

A Missed Opportunity: King of Kings (Angel Studios, 2025)

Angel Studios released an animated story about Jesus called "King of Kings." The movie features a cast of well-known actors and Charles Dickens' work serves as its base. But still, the movie missed a significant opportunity and fell short of sharing the biblical gospel. Instead, Angel Studios made it weird.

Using Charles Dickens as the narrator of Jesus' story launched this movie in the wrong direction from the start. I highly commend Dickens for using his abilities to do his best to disciple his children. He wrote his children a 127-page book of simplified and retold stories from the Gospels, creating a novel-style synthased story of all four gospels. Unfortunately, he did not understand the gospel. The closing charge to his children in the book reads,

"REMEMBER! -- It is christianity TO DO GOOD always--even to those who do evil to us. It is christianity to love our neighbour as ourself, and to do to all men as we would have them DO to us. It is christianity to be gentle, merciful, and forgiving, and to keep those qualities quiet in our own hearts, and never make a boast of them, or of our prayers or of our love of God, but always to shew that we love Him by humbly trying to do right in everything. If we do this, and remember the life lessons of Our Lord Jesus Christ, and try to act up to them, we may confidently hope that God will forgive our sins and mistakes, and enable us to live and die in Peace. THE END." (Life of Our Lord, Westminster: Philadephia, Penn, 1934)

On pages 27-28, Dickens argues that there is hope for the poorest of the poor, saying, "The most miserable, the most ugly, deformed, wretched creatures that live, will be bright Angels in Heaven if they are good here on earth." For Dickens, salvation is about doing more good than evil. It's a works-based salvation plan. Dickens emphasized Jesus' kindness and moral example for his children but dropped much of the more profound teaching about sin, judgment, and the theological depth of the miraculous signs. Dickens presented Jesus as a gracious healer and moral teacher, not the exposer of our sin or the Son who glorifies the Father through suffering and grace.

The movie "King of Kings" ran with a moral story and added a little weirdness of its own. Of course, there will always be Hollywood choices when a narrative goes from one medium to another—in this case, from the written word to a movie. This is expected and often not an issue when those choices involve unclear, unstated matters in the written medium. Such decisions were plentiful. At other times, artistic choices communicated some sort of message. For example, at Jesus' baptism, a spiritual-like dove came out of Jesus and went up toward heaven. On page 23 of Dickens' book, it is clear that the Spirit descended down on Jesus like a dove. This strange addition was all Angel Studios. Another odd moment turned Jesus into Charles Dickens and back, for no apparent reason, although clearly, Angel Studio was trying to make some statement with the change.

Other additions and changes brought more shortcomings to the theological presentation. For example, at one point in the movie, the disciples notice a blind beggar and ask the famous question, "Who sinned, this man or his parents?" Jesus' response was shocking as he said, "It doesn't matter if this man or his parents sinned." He went on to say that the man was blind so we can learn that having faith is what heals—faith in what and why wasn't made clear. Dickens didn't include this story in his book. This was an Angel Studios add-on. But sin does matter. While the disciples misunderstood the cause of his blindness, Jesus' point was that sin is universal and God's sovereign purposes stand above human assumptions, not that sin “doesn't matter.” Jesus has the authority to forgive sin, and the blind receiving sight was a sign to validate that Jesus is the Savior who fulfills the Old Testament promises.

When Jesus was about to be arrested, Peter wrestled a guard's sword out of his hand, and in the skirmish, the man's ear got cut off. It seemed clear that Angel Studios did not want to give Peter a sword. Dickens had no problem with Peter taking a sword with him. It was "his" sword in Dickens' account. Many minor details seemed just a bit off, but this particular one was a change against what the Bible says.

Most of the time, the movie hinted at things but did not offer any clarity. At one point, the Dickens child was processing the reality of Jesus. He was sad and struggling with Jesus' death and resurrection. Artistically, the boy was underwater, sinking as Peter did in an earlier scene. Then, a hand comes into the water to save the boy, and it seems that, like before, Jesus will pull the boy out of the water. Instead, they trade places and Jesus sinks as the boy heads up. Jesus ends up dead on the cross when he is at the bottom. Nothing was said, and this was the closest thing to explaining a substitutionary atonement anywhere in the movie. It was one of many missed opportunities.

At this point, readers might ask why I'm so negative about this movie. It's not worse than watching the next “Mission Impossible” movie, right? Wouldn’t this be better? Maybe. There statement is is both true and untrue. If one is going to watch a film for entertainment, it may be better to watch something with more redeeming value than less. It may be better to watch more wholesome entertainment than much of what is out there.

On the other hand, if the movie claims to be telling the story of God, salvation, and the redemptive work of Jesus Christ but poorly represents all of it, we have a problem on our hands. Unknowing people could go into the theater, hear an incorrect gospel, and then mistakenly follow a good-works, high-moral plan for salvation that does nothing to move them off the road to hell. That's a big problem. If they don’t know Christ, they still don’t know Christ. Only now, they have a substitute and they’ve are less likely to hear about the biblical Jesus.

While I would love to recommend a story about Jesus in the movie theater, I hesitate to recommend this one. It doesn't get the gospel right and opens the door to a truckload of other potential issues. Instead, open your Bible and read the gospel as the good news of God’s redemption meant to be encountered. Rest in it. Delight in it. Be thankful for what God has already done and give yourself to Jesus. Salvation is not about doing good or feeling sad at the right moments. It is a matter of trusting in the finished work of Christ, crucified and risen, for the forgiveness of sins. Anything less—anything else—is not the gospel.

How Long Should I Disciple?

In this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted, Josiah Walker and Bryan Catherman discuss the length of discipleship. How long should I disciple someone? How long should I be discipled? Is there a time that’s too short? Is there a time that’s too long? Is there some plan that’s just right? Too often, people who have spent years learning, attending seminary, and has lived a great deal of life try to run someone through a 1-year plan and expect the disciple will look like the disciple-maker. But how can that be? This is the topic of this episode. Subscribe and listen wherever you get podcasts or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted How Long Should I Disciple?

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

Understanding the Mormon Ethos

Warning: 2 Corinthians 11:4, Galatians 1:8-9 

1.     Mormonism is Relational, Not Theological
In Mormon culture, theology takes a backseat to relationships and family. Doctrinal consistency is seen as less important than maintaining unity and harmony within the LDS community. Theological positions can shift or be reinterpreted to preserve relational bonds or adapt to new cultural pressures. This theological flexibility helps explain how major doctrinal reversals are absorbed with little disruption. Examples include polygamy (D&C 132, 1843; Official Declaration 1, 1890) and race and priesthood (Official Declaration 2, 1978). “Family is forever” is a central organizing principle of Mormonism, often eclipsing fidelity to unchanging truth (The Family: A Proclamation to the World, 1995).

2.     Mormonism is Fluid, Not Grounded
Mormonism has shown a consistent pattern of adjusting not only its doctrines but also its language to suit changing cultural, social, and institutional needs. Terms once embraced, such as Mormon, Mormonism, and LDS Church, have now been officially discouraged by church leaders in favor of the full name, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints—a reversal of decades of public branding, including the famous “I’m a Mormon” campaign. Similarly, core doctrines such as polygamy, priesthood restrictions based on race, and even teachings about the nature of God have undergone redefinition or downplaying to maintain public favor. This rebranding or mainstreaming of beliefs and terminology reflects a broader theological fluidity. Truth is not fixed but reinterpreted as needed. Historically, Mormon leaders (including Joseph Smith) taught that all other Christian churches were apostates or “abominations” (see Joseph Smith History 1:19).

3.     Mormonism is Pragmatic, Not Principled
LDS teachings and priorities often shift depending on practical needs or public image, especially under the influence of the current prophet. Rather than anchoring doctrine in unchanging truth, the church adapts its tone, emphasis, or even beliefs to fit cultural or political moments. A clear example occurred during Mitt Romney’s presidential runs (2008–2012), when church leaders softened distinctive teachings that might seem controversial to mainstream voters. During that time, there was less emphasis on doctrines like eternal progression, exaltation to godhood, and temple ceremonies, while messaging shifted toward family values and belief in Jesus. The goal was not theological clarity but cultural acceptance.

4.     Mormonism is Pliable, Not Firmly-Fixed
In Mormonism, doctrines and beliefs have reshaped over time.  The LDS Church or individual Mormons have adapted standards without reexamining the previous standard’s original meaning or context. D&C 89, known as the “Word of Wisdom,” is a clear example. When first introduced in 1833, early church leaders, including Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, consumed alcohol, tobacco, and tea. Over time, however, later prophets reinterpreted this instruction and made it a strict health code.  Eventually, abstinence from coffee and tea became a requirement for temple worthiness. More recently, the interpretation expanded to include energy drinks and vaping. Individual Mormons pick and choose a different interpretation or develop their own. This evolving application shows how pliable LDS doctrine can be for Mormons.

5.     Mormonism is Self-Based, Not Christ-Based
LDS doctrine places the weight of salvation and eternal progression on the individual’s efforts, making personal worthiness and obedience the foundation for hope in the next life. While grace is mentioned more often in modern LDS teaching, it is still defined as “after all we can do” (2 Nephi 25:23)—meaning Christ’s help only comes once we’ve proven ourselves. Church culture reinforces this by emphasizing personal behavior, rule-keeping, and checklist spirituality. Worthiness interviews, temple recommends, and callings become spiritual scorecards. The typical Mormon feels like he or she can never measure up—it’s never enough.

Understanding LDS Beliefs: In Contrast to the Bible’s Teaching

Be Aware: 2 Corinthians 11:4, Galatians 1:8-9

What is God?

LDS View:
God the Father is an exalted man with a physical body of flesh and bones.  D&C 130:22 states, “The Father has a body of flesh and bones as tangible as man’s […]”  In a funeral sermon for a man named King Follett, Joseph Smith explained that God was once a man as we are now, but he was exalted to godhood, and we can do the same. Any attributes God the Father has today were given to him as he perfected.  Furthermore, God is not eternal, but there was a time when he was not God.  The 5th Prophet of the LDS church, Lorenzo Snow, famously quipped, “As man is, God once was; as God is, man may become.”  Other LDS Prophets and leaders have quoted this to the point that it is now enshrined as an unofficial LDS doctrine. Furthermore, there are many gods in the LDS view.  D&C 132:20 says, “[…] they shall be gods, because they have no end” but it is not concerned with eternality also having no beginning.  The 4th and 5th chapters of the Book of Abraham describe a council of gods or multiple gods creating the world.

What Does the Bible Say?  
Exodus 3:14, Numbers 23:19, Deuteronomy 4:35, Deuteronomy 6:4, 1 Samuel 15:29, 1 Kings 8:27, Psalm 90:2, Psalm 102:25–27, Isaiah 40:18, Isaiah 43:10, Isaiah 43:10–11, Isaiah 44:6–8, Isaiah 45:5, Isaiah 45:5–6, Isaiah 46:9, Hosea 11:9, Malachi 3:6, Matthew 28:19, John 1:1–3, John 4:24, John 17:3, Romans 1:22–25, 1 Corinthians 8:4–6, 2 Corinthians 13:14, Galatians 4:8, Colossians 1:15–17, 1 Timothy 1:17, 1 Timothy 6:15–16, Revelation 1:8, Revelation 4:11

LDS View:
Jesus is the firstborn spirit child of Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother. He was born in the pre-mortal existence or pre-existence.  Lucifer (Satan) is Jesus’ younger spirit brother, just as are all other humans.  Jesus is the same as all humans in every way.  Jesus became a god through progression and obedience and is counted among the Godhead of separate beings that also includes the Father and the Holy Ghost.  He entered Earth to receive a body, just as all humanity expects to do.  Satan and all the spirit children who followed Satan in rebellion against Heavenly Father are denied a body.  (Gospel Principles, ch. 2; Doctrines of Salvation, Joseph Fielding Smith, vol. 1)

What Does the Bible Say?
Genesis 1:26, Deuteronomy 6:4, Numbers 23:19, Micah 5:2, Isaiah 9:6, Isaiah 46:9, Matthew 28:19, John 1:1–3, John 1:14, John 3:31, John 8:58, John 10:30–33, John 14:16–17, John 15:26, John 20:28, 2 Corinthians 13:14, Philippians 2:5–8, Philippians 2:6–7, Colossians 1:16–17, Colossians 2:9, Titus 2:13, Hebrews 1:3, Hebrews 1:8, Hebrews 4:15, Hebrews 7:26, Hebrews 13:8, Revelation 22:13

LDS View:
The Holy Ghost (the preferred LDS term) is an influencing force.  According to the 4th Article of Faith, it is transmitted to a person by laying on hands.  To the one who has not yet received the Holy Ghost, this force confirms the truth of the Book of Mormon and the validity of Prophet Joseph Smith by a “burning in the bosom” to those who genuinely seek this sign.  The Holy Ghost is not to be worshipped and serves mainly as a messenger, personal guide, or guiding influence.   

What Does the Bible Say?
Genesis 1:2, Matthew 28:19, John 14:26, John 16:13–14, Acts 5:3–4, Romans 8:9, 1 Corinthians 3:16, 1 Corinthians 12:11, 2 Corinthians 3:17, Ephesians 1:13–14, Ephesians 4:30, Hebrews 9:14, Titus 3:5, 2 Thessalonians 2:13

 

What is Man? 

LDS View:
All humans are literally the children of Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother.  They were all born prior to the creation of the Earth and were all present at the creation.  D&C 93:29 says, “Man was also in the beginning with God […].” In the pre-existence, every human freely chose to follow God or join Satan in rebellion against God. Those who did not rebel are given the opportunity to come to earth to receive a body and progress toward exaltation (Book of Moses 4:1-4 and Book of Abraham 3:26-28).  According to the 2nd Article of Faith, they do not have a sin nature but are accountable for their own sins committed after their 8th birthday.  Like Heavenly Father and Jesus, they have the opportunity to become a god.   

 What Does the Bible Say?
Genesis 1:26–27, Genesis 2:7, Genesis 3:6–24, Psalm 8:4–5, Psalm 51:5, Psalm 100:3, Ecclesiastes 12:7, Ecclesiastes 12:13, Isaiah 43:7, Isaiah 43:10, Isaiah 44:6–8, Isaiah 46:9, Hosea 11:9, Acts 17:25, John 1:12–13, John 3:3–6, Romans 3:10–12, Romans 5:8, Romans 5:12, Romans 8:7–8, Romans 8:14–17, 1 Corinthians 10:31, 1 Corinthians 15:45–47, 2 Corinthians 5:17, Galatians 4:4–7, Ephesians 2:1–3, Colossians 1:16, Titus 3:5, Hebrews 9:27, 1 John 3:1–2, Revelation 4:11
 

Where Did We Come From? 

LDS View:
Heavenly Father devised a plan for spirit children to come to earth, receive a body, and be tested for exhalation.  This plan included the Fall.  Jesus volunteered to be the Savior, allowing for agency (free will). Lucifer proposed a different plan that would destroy agency.  When his plan was rejected, he rebelled. The Book of Moses 4:1-4 explains that this desire to destroy free will is how Lucifer became the Devil. One-third of the spirit children followed Lucifer and were cast out of heaven. The rest freely chose Jesus and earned the opportunity to be born on earth to get a body and be tested, as outlined in the Book of Abraham 3:27-28. The Fall itself is seen as a positive thing.  2 Nephi 2:25 says, “Adam fell that men might be; and men are, that they might have joy.”  All spirit children are waiting to come to earth so they may get a body.  All angels are either pre-born spirit children humans or faithful human saints who have returned to heaven. Thus, there is no distinct species of angelic beings; instead, angels are humans in either a non-bodied or bodied state.

 What Does the Bible Say?
Genesis 1:26–27, Genesis 2:7, Genesis 3:6–19, Exodus 20:11, Job 38:4–7, Psalm 51:5, Psalm 100:3, Ecclesiastes 12:7, Isaiah 14:12–15, Isaiah 46:9, Ezekiel 28:13–17, Hosea 11:9, Matthew 19:4, John 1:1–3, John 1:12–13, John 3:31, John 8:44, Acts 17:25–26, Acts 17:26, Romans 1:25, Romans 3:10–12, Romans 5:12, 1 Corinthians 15:45–47, 2 Corinthians 5:10, 2 Corinthians 5:17, Ephesians 2:1–3, Colossians 1:16, Titus 3:5, Hebrews 1:13–14, Hebrews 9:27, 1 Peter 1:12, 2 Peter 2:4, Jude 1:6

 

Where Are We Going? 

LDS View:
When we die, every person enters the spirit world, which is divided into spirit paradise and spirit prison. Spirit paradise is for righteous members of the LDS Church, while spirit prison holds those who either rejected or never learned of God’s plan of happiness (Alma 40:11-14). In the spirit prison, there is one more opportunity to accept Jesus (D&C 138:10-34).  While they will not have the opportunity to do the works of progression, their living family members may do them in proxy on their behalf (D&C 124:93-95, 127:5-9, 128:15-18, and an LDS interpretation of 1 Corinthians 15:29).  These include baptism for the dead and marriage sealings.  According to D&C 76:50-113, there will eventually be a final judgment, where people will be assigned to one of three degrees of glory: the Celestial Kingdom (for the faithful who received LDS ordinances), the Terrestrial Kingdom (for moral people who fell short of the full work of progression) or the Telestial Kingdom (for the wicked who eventually accepted Christ after suffering). Only those in the Celestial Kingdom can achieve exaltation, which includes becoming gods and having their own spirit children (D&C 132:19-20 and Book of Abraham chapters 4-5).  A small group of people—called Sons of Perdition—are cast into outer darkness with Satan and his followers. In LDS eschatology, Jesus will reign personally on the earth during a literal Millennium, and the earth will eventually be Celestialized for the exalted to inhabit eternally.

What Does the Bible Say?
Genesis 3:19, Ecclesiastes 9:5–6, Ecclesiastes 12:7, Isaiah 43:10, Isaiah 66:24, Daniel 12:2, Matthew 10:28, Matthew 25:31–46, Luke 16:19–31, John 3:16–18, John 3:18, John 5:24–29, John 14:1–6, John 14:6, Acts 4:12, Romans 2:5–8, Romans 6:23, 1 Corinthians 15:21–23, 2 Corinthians 5:6–10, Galatians 1:8–9, Philippians 3:20–21, Hebrews 9:27, Hebrews 10:26–31, 2 Thessalonians 1:8–9, Revelation 14:9–11, Revelation 20:11–15, Revelation 21:1–8, Revelation 21:8, Revelation 22:14–15 

 

How Do We Get There?  

LDS View:
To get to the Celestial Kingdom, a person must accept the LDS gospel and fully participate in all of the necessary ordinances.  These include faith in Jesus, baptism by immersion by proper priesthood authority, and receiving the gift of the Holy Ghost through the laying on of hands. They must also complete endowment ceremonies, temple marriage (sealing), and ongoing obedience to God’s commandments and the living prophet. According to LDS teaching, grace alone is not sufficient for exaltation. Instead, a person must prove their worthiness through a lifelong process of obedience and progression. 2 Nephi 25:23 says, “It is by grace that we are saved, after all we can do.” Exaltation—living eternally as a god with a spouse, spirit children, and divine authority—is only for those who fully complete these requirements and endure faithfully to the end.

What Does the Bible Say?
Isaiah 43:10, John 1:12–13, John 3:16–18, John 5:24, John 6:28–29, John 14:6, Acts 4:12, Acts 16:30–31, Romans 1:16–17, Romans 3:20–28, Romans 4:1–5, Romans 5:1, Romans 5:8–9, Romans 6:23, Romans 10:9–13, 1 Corinthians 1:18, Galatians 1:6–9, Galatians 2:16, Galatians 3:10–14, Ephesians 1:7, Ephesians 2:8–9, Philippians 3:8–9, Colossians 1:13–14, Titus 3:5–7, Hebrews 7:25, Hebrews 10:14, 1 Peter 3:18, 1 John 5:11–13, Revelation 22:17

Formal and Informal Discipleship

Two women doing a Bible study together.

When we think about discipleship, we quickly think about a program or programming. That’s fine. There’s nothing wrong with formal discipleship. But what about all the other ways we disciple others that do not fit neatly into formal discipleship plans? This is the topic of this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted. Josiah Walker and Bryan Catherman discuss the value of formal and informal discipleship. Subscribe and listen to Salty Believer Unscripted wherever you get good podcasts, or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Formal and Informal Discipleship

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

Discipleship: Have a Plan

Make a plan spelled out in game pieces.

Discipleship is simple obedience in the ordinary. In this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted, Bryan Catherman and Josiah Walker return to the basics, reminding us that discipleship often looks like a consistent, faithful presence in the church's life. They unpack the simplicity and weight of just showing up, investing in relationships, and grounding your walk in the local body of Christ. The key is to have a plan. A simple plan and a complicated plan are still plans. Either way, you need one. Listen to this episode wherever you get the Salty Believer Unscripted podcast or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Discipleship: Have a Plan

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

The Life of Our Lord by Charles Dickens

Charles Dickens sitting at a desk.

Around the time Charles Dickens was completing his novel David Copperfield in 1849, he was quietly working on another manuscript. Unlike his serial publications that captivated Victorian England, this one was not written for the public. It was private and deeply personal. Dickens was writing The Life of Our Lord, a simple, heartfelt retelling of the life of Jesus Christ. He wrote it not for his publisher but for his children. It was, in his own words, “not to be published.” This was a father’s attempt at discipleship. It's an introduction to Jesus, crafted by one of the most gifted storytellers in history.


The work wasn’t made public until long after Dickens’ death. It was first published in 1934, following the death of Dickens’ last surviving child. That makes The Life of Our Lord the final published work of Charles Dickens.

Now, nearly a century after that delayed publication, The Life of Our Lord has been brought to life in a new way. Angel Studios—yes, the folks making The Chosen—has produced an animated film titled The King of Kings. The film features a Charles Dickens-like narrator sharing the story of Jesus with his young son. In doing so, it echoes the quiet discipleship of Dickens' book. It's a father using storytelling to point his children to Christ.

Dickens wasn’t a theologian but he knew Jesus. He used the gifts he had to make Jesus known to his children. That’s the heart of discipleship. We don’t need a publishing deal or a pulpit. We need faith, intentionality, and a willingness to use whatever God has put in our hands—whether it’s a pen, a voice, a meal, or a bedtime story—to point the next generation to Jesus, the King of Kings.

Watch the trailer for the King of Kings here:

Discipleship: Go to Church

The first and most important step in discipleship is to prioritize attending the gathering of the body of Christ. Go to church. Sit under biblical, expositional preaching, sing with the saints, pray corporately, take the Lord’s Supper, celebrate baptisms, etc. It’s how a father can model worship to his family. It’s how we walk in this Christian journey together. In this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted, Josiah Walker and Bryan Catherman discuss how discipleship is simplified and how the foundational step is going to church. Subscribe and listen to Salty Believer Unscripted wherever you get podcasts or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Go to Church

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

Getting to Right Application

How do we know we’re getting the application correct? What do we do when someone in a Bible study pulls out the strangest, out-of-context application from the Text? How do we know we’re on the right track? On this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted, Josiah Walker and Bryan Catherman discuss the danger of getting in the weeds with Bible study application and how to stay on safe footing. Listen wherever you subscribe to podcasts or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Getting to Right Application

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

Baptism and the Lord's Supper

Josiah Walker and Bryan Catherman discuss the two ordinances of the Church: Baptism and the Lord’s Supper. What are these? When do these ordinances happen within the local church? Should you take the Lord’s Supper if you have not been baptized? How do these things relate to membership? What are the different views regarding the Lord’s Supper? How does this work in the Southern Baptist Convention (SBC)? What about the Evangelical Free Church of America (EFCA)? Listen to this episode of Salty Believer Unscripted wherever you get podcasts, or listen here:

Salty Believer Unscripted Baptism and the Lord's Supper

Subscribe to the Salty Believer Unscripted on your favorite podcast app, or use these links:
RSS FeedApple Podcasts | iTunes  | Amazon Music | Audible | Player FM | iHeartRADIO | Pocket Casts | Castbox | Podbean | Spotify | Podcast Addict | Pandora | YouTube

Review: The Art of Prophesying

Perkins, William.  The Art of Prophesying. Edinburgh, UK: Banner of Truth, 1996. 

First published in Latin in 1592 and then in English in 1605, William Perkins'  The Art of Prophesying has long been an expected find on the shelves of most preachers. "Prophesying," in this case, is about preaching or proclaiming the Word of God.  

Perkins was born in 1558 and studied at Christ's College, Cambridge. From 1595 until his death in 1602, he was the preacher at Great St Andrews. History has fixed Perkins' place among the Puritans, chiefly due to his contribution to preaching with the writing of The Art of Prophesying. His 'plain style,' which he used in preaching, also shapes this short book.  

"The better something is," writes Perkins, "the more it deserves to be carefully presented with a wide variety of rich and wise counsel. But this everyday task is frequently described in a scarcely adequate and even improvised matter by comparison with the attention other disciplines receive. I have, therefore, carefully studied the writing of the theologians, composed a series of rules and principles from their teaching and tried to explain them in a way that will be both useful and easily remembered" (4). Perkins achieved his goal, offering an easily understandable explanation of sound principles for preaching.  

Likely bolstered by Perkin's influence, Puritan sermons maintained a basic structure. They opened with a reading of the Word, followed by an explanation of the Scripture. The next part of the sermon revolved around any doctrines touched by the sermon Text. In many ways, the middle portion of a Puritan sermon is a study of systematics. Finally, "If the preacher is suitably gifted," writes Perkins, "applying the doctrines thus explained to the life and practice of the congregation in straightforward, plain speech" concludes the sermon. (87) "Uses" is often the Purtain term for application.  The Art of Prophesying assumes this format for every sermon.  

The book opens with a discussion of what Scripture is, followed by a discussion of how to study and explain it clearly. Chapter four is titled "The Interpretation of Scripture." "Principles for Expounding Scripture" comes next, then "Rightly Handling the Word of God." Eventually, Perkins offers a couple of chapters on applying the Text or "uses." Finally, the book moves to some basic "how to preach" material.  

The Art of Prophesying is a short, easy read. It's a long-standing classic, and anyone who identifies as a preacher should have read it. A word of caution, however. Perkins was writing for another time, and the reader should keep the age of this book's birth and Perkins as a preacher in mind. Most modern sermons follow similar rules and principles, but not as rigidly. The book's greatest weakness is found in the absoluteness of the way to preach, leaving little room for any variation as the Text itself may demand of the preacher and his sermon. Otherwise, The Art of Prophesying is a must-read for preachers and those who desire to one day preach. At only 87 pages, Perkins should be assigned reading in every seminary preaching class. 

Mark’s Three Endings

     Consider the end of Mark 16. The task may be challenging. Where does Mark 16 end? The last undebatable verse is 8. Mark 16:8 may be where Mark intended to conclude the book. Yet many translations run to verse 20. Depending on the translation, there may be brackets around verses 9-20. There may be a footnote about these same verses.  

     Some translations, like the NLT, NRSV, CNT, or CEB, have two endings. After verse 8, in those translations, it reads: "And all that has been commanded to them they quickly reported to those around Peter. After these things, Jesus himself sent out throughout them from east to west, the holy and imperishable proclamation of eternal salvation, Amen." This addition is one of two proposed endings that pick up after verse 8, and it's likely in brackets. A second alternative is what we typically see in other Bible translations, which is verses 9-20. Given that both proposed endings pick up after verse 8, most scholars believe one of two things: either the last part of Mark's gospel was torn off and lost after verse 8, or the book ended at verse 8.  

     Most Greek readers see that the additional ending differs from the rest of Mark. The style and word choices are not consistent. The different ending is called the Byzantine Text. One finds neither of the two additional endings in the earliest known manuscripts.   

     The original ending could have been lost. Perhaps one of the two endings was verbally handed down over the years, and eventually, a scribe added it in writing, reclaiming what was lost. Maybe God superintended later inspiration to a scribe. Many have put arguments forward.  

     Or, it is possible that Mark, inspired by the Holy Spirit, intended the book to end abruptly at verse 8. If so, what might the reason be? Reading the text as if it were the intended ending, the messenger expected the ladies to believe the message. If they believed, they would tell others. But Mark wasn't concerned about those women--he wrote the gospel with concern for his readers. Mark has placed his readers in the same spot as the women. Will the reader believe? If so, will the reader tell others? The ending in this shape is abrupt, but it seems fitting given the purpose of the Gospel. It places the reader in a sharp position to respond with belief and proclamation. It may be well worth teaching or preaching to Mark as if verse 8 is the end. 

Who Can Stand? (Revelation 6:17)

Revelation 6 begins with the Lamb opening the first of seven seals on the scroll taken from the one on the throne. After a quick progression of events, Jesus opens the sixth seal. Kings and nobles, generals, the rich and the poor, and the free and the slaves realize the coming judgment of God. To the mountains they flee, pleading with the rocks to fall and them so that by their physical death they might escape the face of the one seated on the throne. Revelation 6:17 ends with their question: "Who can stand?"  

Translations have rendered this differently, but the question remains. Who is able to stand in the face of this wrath? Unfortunately, the NET renders the word, ἵστημι (histēmi) as "withstand." The NLT paraphrases the meaning as "survive." The NIV-11 changed the NIV-84's "stand" to "withstand." It may not seem to make much of a difference when viewed as a single translation in a single verse, but it makes a world of difference when seen next to the additional three uses of ἵστημι (histēmi) in the following verses in Revelation 7.   

The question of people under wrath and judgment asks, "Who can stand?" Then John, inspired by God, shows us the answer. Engaging a keen eye for repeated words, ἵστημι (histēmi) is attention-grabbing. There is it three times. Revelation 7:1, 9, and 11.  

Don't overlook the great multitude from every nation, tribe, people, and language standing before the throne and before the Lamb. Those asking the question, "Who can stand?" want to be hidden from the one seated on the throne and from the wrath of the Lamb. Who can stand? John wants the reader to see that the answer is undoubtedly those. In Revelation 7:13, one of the elders in heaven asks John who these standing before the throne are. He could have just told John, but by asking, it's as if John is questioning the reader. Who are these people standing before God? The elder answers, "These are the ones coming out of the great tribulation. They have washed their robes and made them white in the blood of the Lamb." 

Undoubtedly, the question, "Who can stand?" and the answer lead us to the more meaningful theme of Revelation 6 and 7. It is tempting to get sidelined in the seals and the meaning of the 144,000, but those details must be submitted to this more central, more significant point. Who can stand? Now we know. 

Repeated Ideas Help Bring Out Meaning

Repeated words in a passage of Scripture, chapter, or even a whole book are valuable signposts that often help us uncover the meaning of a Text. But sometimes, the words themselves do not repeat--the ideas do. A good Bible expositor should have a trained ear for repeated words and ideas.  

For example, the third temptation of Satan in Luke 4 plays out through a repeated idea and pattern when almost none of the words repeat.  

Luke 4:9-12 says, "And he [Satan] took him [Jesus] to Jerusalem and set him on the pinnacle of the temple and said to him, 'If you are the Son of God, throw yourself down from here, for it is written, 'He will command his angels concerning you, to guard you,' and 'One their hands they will bear you up, lest you strike your foot against a stone.' And Jesus answered him, 'It is said, 'You shall not put the Lord God to the test'" (ESV, italics added for emphasis).

After Jesus preached in the Nazarene Synagogue, the people tried to kill him. Luke 4:28-30 says, "When they heard these things, all in the synagogue were filled with wrath. And they rose up and drove him out of the town and brought him to the brow of the hill on which their town was built, so that they could throw him down the cliff. But passing through their midst, he went away" (italics added for emphasis).

Then Jesus confronted a demon. Luke 4:35 says, "But Jesus rebuked him, saying, 'Be Silent and come out of him!' And when the demon had thrown him down in their midst, he came out of him, having done him no harm" (italics added for emphasis).     

There's a repeating idea and pattern. The Greek words behind "throw him down" are not the same. ("βάλε σεαυτὸν ἐντεῦθεν," "κατακρημνίσαι αὐτόν," and "ῥῖψαν αὐτὸν.") Yet, the idea of throwing down or being thrown down or being cast down is the same. And there's a claim of protection that follows. No harm comes. Satan quoted Psalm 91, saying that God will guard and not even a foot will hit a stone. Luke carefully pointed out that Jesus was not thrown off a cliff but passed through their midsts. God protected him. And when the demon threw the man down, Luke carefully noted that the man was not harmed.  

The Old Testament Scriptures quoted by Satan and Jesus bring out even more meaning from this repeated pattern. Satan cited Psalm 91:11-12. That psalm opens by saying, "He who dwells in the shelter of the Most High will abide in the shadow of the Almighty. I will say to the Lord, 'My refuge and my fortress, my God, in whom I trust.'" It goes on to proclaim that God will deliver from all the snares and traps of the fouler. Remarkably, verse 13, following what Satan quoted, says, "You will tread on the lion and the adder; the young lion and the serpent you will trample underfoot." Then, verses 14-16 bring a powerful message of hope of salvation and protection from God. They say, "Because he holds fast to me in love, I will deliver him; I will protect him because he knows my name.  When he calls to me, I will answer him; I will be with him in trouble; I will rescue him and honor him.  With long life I will satisfy him and show him my salvation."  

Jesus responded to Satan by quoting the first part of Deuteronomy 6:16 -- "You shall not put the Lord your God to the test." The verse continues, saying, "as you tested him at Massah." The Massah event (Exodus 17:1-7) is when the people grumbled against Moses because they had no water and believed they would die. Moses asked why they were testing God, which was a way of pointing out that they did not trust God and were not in obedience to the Lord. Then, God provided water from a stone. Deuteronomy 6 continues with instructions to obey God's commandments because it will go well. It is a picture of trusting rather than doubting the Lord.     

With these quoted passages in view, the pattern of trust and protection becomes much more significant throughout the chapter. The Old Testament passages were not reserved for Jesus but encouragement and instruction to all of God's people. The three-fold pattern seen from Satan's temptation to the demon unable to harm the person opens up a great deal of meaning from this passage.  

The point: Look not just for repeated words but also for repeated ideas.  

The Melodic Line of Luke-Acts

Approaching Luke without considering Acts or approaching with Acts without considering Luke is as misguided as reading half of a murder-mystery novel and never returning to the book.  These are two parts of one work.  While still two books (as Luke names them in Acts 1:1), they are married to make one narrative. 

  It is a mistake to think that the book of Luke is about Jesus and the book of Acts is about the Holy Spirit, or the Apostles, or the Church.  Both books are about Jesus and his work.  The author (Luke) said that he wrote Luke to show Theophilus that he could be certain about what he was taught regarding Christ (Luke 1:1-4).  In the opening of Acts, he clarified his purpose for the book of Luke, writing, “In the first book, O Theophilus, I have dealt with all that Jesus began to do and teach, until the day when he was taken up” (Acts 1:1-2a, italics added).  The implication is that Acts accounts for what Jesus continued to do after his ascension.  The line between the two volumes is the ascension, shown at the end of Luke and the beginning of Acts (Luke 24:51 and Acts 1:9).  The overlap connects and divides the two books. Yet, the reality of Jesus’ saving work is at the core of both books. 

  Acts does indeed show the actions of the Holy Spirit, a small sample of the Apostles, and the Church, but these are the means by which Jesus continues his salvific mission while seated at the right hand of the Father.  The melodic line running through the two books exposes what is happening in both books. 

  The melodic line (a term favored by the Charles Simeon Trust) is the idea that just as every song has a unique, identifiable melody, every book of the Bible has a similar melody running from start to finish.  It is the significant theme with reoccurring “notes” by which the book moves along.  It is the message of the entire book, and it helps the reader understand how each passage relates to that key message.  Luke and Acts share the same melodic line.  They fit snugly together.   

  One note of the melodic line is the word “salvation.”  The word and similar words like “saved” ring often.  Another note is “believe” and similar words like “belief.”  In the book of Luke, the salvation/saved note plays at 1:69, 1:71-77, 2:30, 3:6, 6:9, 7:50, 8:12, 9:24, 13:23, 18:26, 19:9-10, and 23:35-39. Believe/belief rings out at 1:20, 1:45, 8:12-13, 8:50, 20:5, 22:67, 24:11, and 22:25.  This should be expected of a gospel, the good news of Jesus Christ in Luke.  But the melody continues to play in Acts.  Salvation and saved show up in Acts 2:21, 2:40, 2:47, 4:12, 7:25, 11:14, 13:36, 13:47, 15:1, 15:11, 16:17, 16:30-31, 27:20, 27:31, 27:43, and 28:28.  Belief and believe show up in Acts 2:44, 4:4, 4:32, 5:14, 8:12-13, 9:26, 9:42, 10:43, 10:45, 11:17, 11:21, 13:12, 13:39, 13:41, 13:48-49, 14:1, 14:23, 15:5, 15:7, 15:11, 16:1, 16:31, 16:34, 17:12, 17:34, 18:8, 18:27, 19:2, 19:4, 19:18, 21:20, 21:25, 22:19, 24:14, and 26:27. 

  Some of the melody notes found at the beginning of Luke and the end of Acts are echoed at the end of Luke and the beginning of Acts. Luke opens with a statement about John, who will turn people's hearts to the Savior (Luke 1:16-17).  At the birth of Jesus, Mary sings that Jesus will “give knowledge of salvation to his people” (1:77).  Simeon says he saw God’s salvation when he held Jesus as a baby (2:30).  And in Luke 3:6, Luke quotes Isaiah’s statement that “all flesh will see the salvation of God.” At the end of Acts, Paul speaks of a people never hearing or seeing, but then says, “Let it be known to you that his salvation of God has been sent to the Gentiles, and they will listen” (Acts 28:28).  The bookends of the two-volume work shout of salvation. The message of salvation runs through both books. At the end of Luke, Jesus appoints his disciples to proclaim repentance and forgiveness of sins because Christ rose from the dead (Luke 24:46-47).  In the opening of Acts, Jesus calls his disciples to be his witnesses (Acts 1:8) to proclaim Jesus’ message of salvation.  Paul preaches that they were “sent the message of salvation” (13:26).  Even the girl possessed by a demon declared that Paul and Barnabas were preaching the way of salvation (16:17).  Luke and Acts are about salvation found “in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given among men by which we must be saved,” as Peter preached in Acts 4:12.    

  Another note of the melody is Jesus in the middle of the action.  Luke sets the stage, but that part of the melody does not end in Acts.  It is the opposite.  Jesus calls those who are far off in Acts 2:39. It is Jesus adding new believers to his church in Acts 2:47 and 11:21.  Jesus sent the angel to open the doors of the jail (5:19 and 12:11).  Jesus gives direction to his disciples in 8:26 and 9:11. It is Jesus who opens the hearts of those who hear the preached word (16:14). He strikes down his enemies in (12:23).  Jesus reveals himself to Stephen in 7:59-60 and appears to Saul in 9:11. Jesus speaks to Saul (9:5, 18:9, 23:11), to Cornelius (10:4), and to Peter (10:14).  And Jesus called Paul to preach the gospel in 20:24. People were healed, raised from the dead, and called upon to believe in and by the name of Jesus.  The name of Jesus (not even counting all the times he’s only referred to as “the Lord”) appears 71 times in the 28-chapter book of Acts.  Jesus is the chief actor in the Book of Acts.   

  Still, another note is the constant reversal of expectations when those who the world perceives to be outsiders (women, the poor, the sick, tax collectors, and gentiles) are brought into a relationship with God.  Jesus is bringing salvation to all people.  What was clearly shown in Luke continues in Acts, especially with the Gentiles, and Jesus is present and working in both books.  In Luke, Jesus preached much (but not all) of the proclamation of the Good News.  In Acts, Jesus uses the means of the Apostles and the Church to make the same proclamation of the gospel, empowered by the Holy Spirit, whom Jesus promised he would provide (Luke 12:11-12).

  Nancy Guthrie offers an outstanding discussion of the melodic line of Luke and Acts in her book Saved (Crossway, 2024), which was, in part, used in the preparation of this article.  Her proposed melodic line of Luke is, “God is working for the salvation of his people through the incarnation, Jesus’s sinless life, his death, and his resurrection” (6).  For the book of Acts, she suggests, “The Lord Jesus is continuing to work out God’s eternal plan of salvation for his people through his ascension, his session as he sits at God’s right hand ruling over and interceding for us, and in pouring out his Spirit at Pentecost” (6-7).  She goes on to clarify that God’s people are from all the earth, “every tribe and language” (Revelation 5:9).   

  Luke and Acts show us that Jesus’ work brings salvation to and for all people who repent and believe.  This is true whether during Jesus’ earthly ministry or beyond.  It is even true before his earthly ministry.  Any study of Luke or Acts should be grounded in the line that runs through both books. 

Review: The Charles Simeon Trust

The Charles Simeon Trust, simeontrust.org, (date of this review: January 1, 2025).

The Charles Simeon Trust was officially organized in January 2001 by David Helm, John Dennis, Kent Huges, and two silent partners, although that is not its genesis. Built on the echo of Dick Lucas' Proclamation Trust (London), the Workshop on Biblical Exposition was an annual event at Wheaton that grew into the need for something more. Today, that something--the Charles Simeon Trust--provides preaching workshops around the country, online courses, resources, and a resident program called the Chicago Course.

Bible expositors should not only be aware of the Charles Simeon Trust but also attend a workshop and take online courses. Workshop leaders encourage attendees to view their time at the 2-and-a-half-day gathering as a pro baseball player approaches spring training. It's an opportunity to return to the fundamentals and correct bad habits. Yet, it's more than spring training--the Charles Simeon Trust is a robust basket of preaching training that far surpasses seminary homiletical courses.

Strong, time-tested tools explained and wielded by a time-tested cadre of strong leaders bring vibrance and excellence to the lecture portion of the workshop—the same lectures that make up the online courses. Providing ample time for smaller group practice, where each man brings his expositional work for discussion by the group, makes a Charles Simeon Trust workshop unlike any other preaching conference. It also provides a space for the preaching tools taught in the lectures to be placed into the hands of the attendees for supervised practice.

The Charles Simeon Trust offers tremendous value to anyone who opens God's Word and preaches or teaches it to others. However, the organization struggles to get the expositor all the way home. For more than 20 years, David Helm has led his workshop leaders to train preachers in sermon preparation, but they've come up short in sermon delivery.* They've got the work in the preacher's study dialed in but awkwardly overlook what he still needs to do when he steps into the pulpit with his well-prepared sermon outline. That oversight, however, is not enough to steer any preacher away from the Charles Simeon Trust. They remain a must-experience for any faithful expositor.

*At the time of this article, this reviewer is aware of work the Charles Simeon Trust is doing to strengthen this area of its training, having seen and discussed research and experienced experimental cohorts that may become additional tools provided by the Charles Simeon Trust. Let us look forward to this extra help for preachers everywhere!

How Many Luke?: An Interpretation of Luke 1:1-4

Luke, the author of Luke and Acts, opens his first volume by claiming that "many have undertaken to compile a narrative of the things that have been accomplished among us" (1:1). Commentators and preachers often race past this statement, wanting to move on to the identities and attributes of Luke and Theophilus. This is a grave mistake because the identity of the “many” ties Luke's work to the Old Testament and says a great deal about how the author thinks of himself. Furthermore, Luke's first sentence is a powerhouse statement for the continuity of the Old and New Testaments.

One popular take is that "many" refers to not only Matthew, Mark, and John but maybe even additional writings from the other Apostles, plus the biographical accounts written by various disciples and even perhaps accounts of Jesus's earthy life written by non-believers. As the argument implies, bookstores were teaming with biographies of Jesus, and Luke joined the stack in the shop window. However, unlike the others, Luke wanted to get the facts correct through careful study and interviews with the eyewitnesses. This view raises many questions that it fails to answer. Did none of these other accounts survive except for Mathew, Mark, and John? How were there so many authors willing to write a positive account of the "criminal" whose followers the Romans and the Jewish religious leaders were persecuting, jailing, and even executing? Assuming Luke's gospel was the last of the four, why would he not simply point Theophilus to any of the other three if he merely wanted Theophilus to get the facts correct? Is it possible that Luke didn't think Matthew, Mark, or John were correct?

Continuing this line of thought, verses 1 and 2 raise more questions. To whom is Luke referring in verse 1 by saying "us"? What "things" have been "accomplished" or fulfilled? Is he only speaking of things during Jesus' earthly ministry or pointing to something more? As Luke moves to verse 2, he says what he is attempting is just like "those who from the beginning were eyewitnesses and ministers of the word and delivered them to us." If what he is doing is like "those people," it would be helpful to identify who those people might be. Does he mean people who were eyewitnesses of Jesus' earthly ministry from the beginning or someone else witnessing something more? These witnesses and ministers of the word delivered their writings to "us." Luke opened with the same word John opened with--λογοσ (logos), which is translated as "the word," and of those who delivered this word, Luke calls “ministers of the word.” Is what Luke is referring to inspired Scripture, breathed out by God? If that only includes Matthew, Mark, and John, is "many" accurate? Why would God allow Scripture to be lost if it refers to additional inspired manuscripts?

There is another way to think about Luke's opening statement. If "us" refers to the people of God (which, by conversion, Luke had become), then he could be pointing to all the ministers of the word from the Old Testament who documented all that God had been accomplishing among his people. This approach significantly agrees with Luke's comparison in verse 2, just like those who, from the beginning, could include Moses, the prophets, and many more. They were eyewitnesses of God's works, and Luke says he's writing an account of the eyewitnesses in his generation. Many delivered the accounts of the Old Testament, written down for others to have certainty, and just like that, Luke is writing an account and delivering it to Theophilus. Luke saw himself as continuing the account that started long ago and was continuing and being fulfilled in his time. Luke 24:27 and 44 lend tremendous credit to this interpretation of Luke 1:1-2.

If the latter view is correct, Luke opens with a strong tie to the Old Testament. Given how many Old Testament quotes and allusions Luke depends on, it's only fitting that he sees his work as an articulation of the accomplishment of Old Testament promises. Luke tells of all that fulfills what the Old Testament anticipates in the Savior. Knowing this reality, he states it up front so Theophilus can be sure of everything he learned from the Old Testament, which, incidentally, also finds strong support from Luke 24:27 and 44. Taking this approach to Luke 1:1-4 makes a strong argument for the account of Jesus' earthly ministry and also for what the Old Testament says about Jesus. This view is a far more robust understanding of what it means to be an eyewitness of all that God has done and is still doing.

Sign or No Sign?

John was in prison, but word about Christ's deeds still reached him. Jesus instructed the two disciples John sent to return and tell John what they saw. When the disciples asked if Jesus was the Messiah they had been hoping for, he pointed to the blind receiving sight, the lame walking, lepers cleansed, the deaf hearing, the dead raised, and the good news preached to the poor (Matthew 11:1-6).

Not much later, scribes and Pharisees asked Jesus for a sign. Presumably, they wanted proof that he was the Messiah they had been waiting for. This time, Jesus told them, "An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a sign, but no sign will be given it except the sign of the prophet Jonah" (Matthew 12:39). John the Baptist sent for encouragement, and he was told to look at the events of Jesus' ministry. The Pharisees demanded a sign to prove that Jesus was who he claimed to be, and they were rebuked, called an evil generation who would only receive the sign of Jonah. Which is it? Why the difference?

In both cases, the deeds of Christ were evident. The blind, lame, lepers, deaf, and dead received the miracles prophesied in Isaiah 29:18-18, 35:5-6, and 61:1. These may have been the deeds John had already heard about. Yet, when John was genuinely seeking the Messiah, he was gently reminded to see the fulfillment of Scripture in the events of Christ's ministry. The Pharisees, however, were already set on rejecting the events and demanding Jesus prove himself by their terms. They had already rejected Christ. Therefore, Jesus told them the only sign a wicked and evil generation would receive was the sign of Jonah.

Jesus went on to describe one aspect of the sign of Jonah--that just as Jonah was in the fish for three days, so the Son of Man will be three days in the earth. But this is less of a sign than what Jesus says next. "The men of Nineveh will rise up at the judgment with this generation and condemn it, for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and behold, something greater than Jonah is here" (Matthew 12:41).

The more excellent sign of Jonah is repentance. Everyone but Jonah repents and willingly obeys God in the book of Jonah except Jonah. Creation submits to God even when Jonah does not. Yet the book of Jonah ends with another chance for repentance. Because Jesus will be in the earth for three days, repentance and salvation are possible. One must repent if one desires to see and believe that Jesus is who he says he is. As their actions showed, the Pharisees had already rejected that sign.

When preaching either Text—Matthew 11:1-6 or 12:38-41—the contrast between John the Baptist and the Pharisees provides a straightforward approach to presenting repentance in light of Jesus's deeds. These two events are well-tied together and worth seeing side-by-side.

Getting Started in Jonah

Jonah is probably the Minor Prophet most people know best. That familiarity is a gift, but it can also be a problem. Many people know Jonah was swallowed by a great fish. Fewer know why the book was written the way it was written.

Jonah is unlike the other prophetic books. It is short. It is narrative. It is memorable. Because it is only four chapters, preachers often choose Jonah for a four-part series. That can be a good choice. The trouble comes when the series simply follows the chapter breaks as if Stephen Langton’s divisions were part of the original manuscript. Chapter breaks can be useful. They can also quietly train us to miss the shape of the text.

Jonah is much more than a man and a fish. The fish matters, of course. Jesus mentions it. But Jonah is much more than a prophet being swallowed and spit out. It is a sharp, carefully structured book that exposes the human heart, displays the sovereign mercy of God, and calls the reader to repentance and worship.

That makes Jonah a wonderful book for preaching, teaching, and personal study. It is short enough to read in one sitting and deep enough to expose things we would rather leave undisturbed.

Jonah Is Two Parallel Narratives

The structure of Jonah is formed by two parallel narratives. The second narrative mirrors the first, but more largely and deeply. This allows the book to teach its lessons by taking the reader through a pattern once and then taking the reader through the pattern again with greater intensity.

The opening lines of the two narratives echo one another:

“Now the word of the Lord came to Jonah…” (Jonah 1:1)
“Then the word of the Lord came to Jonah the second time…” (Jonah 3:1)

From there, the narratives follow a repeated sequence.

First narrative: Jonah 1-2

  1. The word of the Lord comes to Jonah (Jonah 1:1-2).

  2. Jonah acts in response by fleeing (Jonah 1:3).

  3. Non-Israelites enter the picture through the sailors (Jonah 1:4-16).

  4. God demonstrates his sovereignty over creation by appointing the storm and the fish (Jonah 1:4, 17).

  5. Jonah prays (Jonah 2:1-9).

  6. God acts by speaking to the fish, and Jonah is delivered (Jonah 2:10).

Second narrative: Jonah 3-4

  1. The word of the Lord comes to Jonah again (Jonah 3:1-2).

  2. Jonah acts in response by going to Nineveh (Jonah 3:3-4).

  3. Non-Israelites enter the picture through the Ninevites (Jonah 3:5-9).

  4. God demonstrates his sovereignty in mercy, then through the plant, worm, and wind (Jonah 3:10; 4:6-8).

  5. Jonah prays (Jonah 4:1-4).

  6. God acts by teaching Jonah and pressing him with a final question (Jonah 4:5-11).

This structure matters. Jonah does not merely move from chapter 1 to chapter 2 to chapter 3 to chapter 4. It moves through a pattern, then repeats the pattern with greater depth. The first half teaches us how to read the second half. The second half exposes the deeper issue in Jonah and brings the reader into the uncomfortable place where Jonah stands.

In the first narrative, Jonah’s disobedience is visible. He runs from the word of the Lord. In the second narrative, Jonah obeys outwardly, but his heart is exposed. He goes to Nineveh, preaches judgment, watches the city repent, and becomes angry because God shows mercy.

In chapter 1, Jonah’s feet run from God. In chapter 4, Jonah’s heart argues with God. That is why the parallel structure is so important. Jonah’s problem is not only that he tried to run far away. His deeper problem is that he does not love mercy when God gives it to his enemies.

Everyone Obeys Except Jonah

One of the most striking features of Jonah is that the reader should expect Jonah, the prophet of the Lord, to obey God. Instead, in a shocking reversal, everyone and everything seems to obey the Lord except Jonah. God commands the storm. The storm obeys. God appoints the fish. The fish obeys. God speaks to the fish. The fish obeys. The sailors fear the Lord. The Ninevites repent. God appoints a plant. It obeys. God appoints a worm. It obeys. God appoints a scorching east wind. It obeys. Meanwhile, Jonah runs, sleeps, resists, complains, and sulks.

This is not accidental. The book wants us to notice the irony. The pagans respond more properly than the prophet. The wicked city repents more quickly than the preacher. Creation obeys God while Jonah argues with him. That should slow down any preacher or teacher who wants to turn Jonah into a simple lesson about evangelism, courage, or missionary obedience. Those themes are present, but Jonah is not mainly a ministry recruitment poster with a fish on it. Jonah exposes the heart of a man who knows true things about God but struggles to love what God loves.

The Abrupt Ending Is the Point

Jonah ends abruptly. God asks Jonah whether he should not pity Nineveh, that great city, in which there are more than 120,000 persons who do not know their right hand from their left, and also much cattle (Jonah 4:11). Then the book ends. No final speech from Jonah. No neat resolution. No tidy line about how Jonah learned his lesson. Nothing. That abrupt ending is not a flaw. It is one of the book’s sharpest tools.

The first narrative teaches the complete pattern. It is like A+B+C=D. Jonah rebels, God pursues, Jonah is brought low, Jonah prays, Jonah confesses the truth, and Jonah is delivered. The right response is repentance and worship.

The second narrative gives the pattern again, but larger. It is like AA+BB+CC=__. The reader is supposed to know the answer. Jonah should repent and worship again, but this time the repentance should go deeper because the issue is deeper. He must not only confess that salvation belongs to the Lord when God saves him. He must also confess that salvation belongs to the Lord when God saves Nineveh.

Once we know what Jonah should do, we know what we should do. That is the trapdoor under the reader. Jonah is not merely asking whether Nineveh should receive mercy. Jonah is asking whether we trust God to be merciful to whomever he pleases.

Three Big Themes in Jonah

Jonah is short, but it is not thin. Several themes stand out for preachers and teachers.

The Fear of the Lord

Jonah’s first response to God’s command is resistance. The word of the Lord comes, but Jonah rises to flee. The movement could almost be summarized this way: “The Lord said, but Jonah.” When the word of the Lord comes again in Jonah 3, the movement changes. This time Jonah goes. The contrast matters. Jonah is learning, but he is not finished learning. His outward obedience in chapter 3 is real, but chapter 4 reveals that his heart is still struggling with God’s mercy.

The fear of the Lord is more than bare submission. It includes trust. Jonah must learn that God is not only sovereign over storms, fish, plants, worms, and wind. God is also right in his mercy. Jonah does not get to approve God’s compassion before God may extend it. This is a needed lesson. Many Christians can obey God externally while quietly judging God internally. We can serve, teach, preach, give, attend, and even do the right thing while our hearts object to God’s generosity toward others. Jonah puts that ugliness on the table and refuses to let us call it maturity.

Salvation Belongs to the Lord

Jonah’s great confession comes from the belly of the fish: “Salvation belongs to the Lord” (Jonah 2:9). This is one of the central lines of the book. Jonah is not saved because he has finally become impressive. The sailors are not spared because Jonah managed the crisis well. Nineveh is not spared because Jonah preached with warmth, tears, and a compelling three-point invitation. God saves because salvation belongs to the Lord. This truth is both comforting and humbling. It comforts us because God can save stubborn prophets, terrified sailors, wicked cities, and sinners like us. It humbles us because God does not need our permission to show mercy.

Jonah knows the truth, but he struggles to love it. He receives God’s mercy for himself, then resents God’s mercy for Nineveh. That is the rotten center of the book. Jonah loves grace when grace rescues Jonah. He is far less enthusiastic when grace reaches his enemies. The book will not let us admire grace in theory while despising it in practice.

God’s Patience and Grace

God is astonishingly patient with Jonah. Jonah runs, and God pursues him. Jonah sinks, and God appoints a fish. Jonah prays, and God delivers him. Jonah preaches reluctantly, and God saves Nineveh. Jonah fumes, and God reasons with him. Jonah wants to die, and God teaches him with a plant, a worm, and a question. God could have ended Jonah early. He does not. That is grace.

God’s grace to Nineveh is obvious. God’s grace to Jonah may be even more stunning because Jonah knows better. He knows God’s character. He knows God’s mercy. He knows God’s covenant name. Yet God patiently shepherds him. This makes Jonah helpful for teaching sanctification. Jonah goes around the mountain more than once. He learns something in chapter 2, but chapter 4 shows that the lesson must go deeper. That is familiar to every Christian who has ever had to relearn the same lesson with slightly different scenery and more embarrassing details. God is gracious to slow learners. That should not make us lazy. It should make us worship.

God’s Sovereignty in Mission

Jonah also shows God’s sovereignty in mission. God sends his word where he wants it to go. Jonah’s selfishness does not stop God. Jonah’s reluctance does not stop God. Nineveh’s wickedness does not stop God. Creation itself is ready to serve God’s saving purposes. This does not excuse Jonah. God’s sovereignty never turns human disobedience into faithfulness. It does, however, give hope. God can work through weak, reluctant, and badly motivated messengers. That is mercy.

God cares about sailors Jonah ignores. God cares about Ninevites Jonah hates. God cares about a city Jonah would rather see destroyed. Jonah’s mission exposes Jonah’s heart, but it also displays God’s heart.

Why a Four-Part Series Should Not Simply Follow the Chapters

A four-sermon series through Jonah is a good idea. But the easiest plan may not be the best plan. Many preachers would naturally preach Jonah something like this:

  1. Jonah runs from God, chapter 1.

  2. Jonah prays from the fish, chapter 2.

  3. Jonah preaches to Nineveh, chapter 3.

  4. Jonah gets angry, chapter 4.

That series would not be heresy. But it may miss the structure of the book.

The problem is that Jonah 1 and 3 belong together in important ways. Both begin with the word of the Lord coming to Jonah. Both show Jonah responding. Both bring non-Israelites into the story. Both show God’s sovereign work. Both display surprising responses from people we might not expect to respond.

Likewise, Jonah 2 and 4 belong together. Both are prayers from Jonah. In Jonah 2, Jonah prays from distress and moves toward confession, repentance, and worship. In Jonah 4, Jonah prays from anger and still needs to be led toward the right response. Chapter 2 helps us know what should happen after chapter 4.

Therefore, a four-part series may better serve the Text by spending two sermons in Jonah and two sermons in the New Testament.

A Better Four-Sermon Path

Here is one way to preach Jonah in four sermons while honoring the book’s structure and showing its fulfillment in Christ.

Sermon 1: The Word of the Lord and the Fear of the Lord

Text: Jonah 1 and 3
Main idea: The word of the Lord exposes whether we fear God by trusting and obeying him.

This sermon should compare the two beginnings. In Jonah 1, the word comes and Jonah runs. In Jonah 3, the word comes and Jonah goes. The contrast is simple, but it opens the book’s deeper concern.

In Jonah 1, the sailors increasingly fear the Lord while Jonah resists. In Jonah 3, Nineveh repents at the preaching of Jonah. In both chapters, the people we least expect to respond are the ones responding. Jonah, the prophet, remains the troubling figure.

The sermon can press the difference between outward familiarity with God and proper fear of God. Jonah knows true theology, but he does not yet trust God’s mercy. The fear of the Lord includes believing that God is right, even when his commands and compassion confront our preferences.

Sermon 2: Repentance, Worship, and the Grace of God

Text: Jonah 2 and 4
Main idea: God graciously brings sinners around again and again so they may repent, yield, and worship.

This sermon should compare Jonah’s two prayers. In chapter 2, Jonah prays from the fish and comes to the great confession that salvation belongs to the Lord. In chapter 4, Jonah prays from anger and reveals that he resents God’s mercy to Nineveh.

The preacher can show Jonah taking two trips around the mountain. In the first, God brings Jonah low, Jonah sees God’s mercy, and Jonah worships. In the second, God brings Jonah into another lesson, but this time we get to hear the conversation. Jonah is still struggling. God is still gracious. Jonah wants to die. God reasons with him. Jonah pities the plant. God points him to the city. The ending invites the reader to respond. Jonah should repent and worship. So should we.

This sermon has a strong sanctification angle. Christians often learn the same gospel truths repeatedly. We are saved by grace, being sanctified by grace, and will be brought home by grace. God walks his people through repentance more than once because our hearts are often slower than our mouths.

Sermon 3: The Sign of Jonah and the Gospel of Jesus

Text: Matthew 12:38-42 or Luke 11:29-32
Main idea: Jesus teaches us that Jonah points beyond himself to the greater prophet, the greater sign, and the gospel of repentance and forgiveness.

If we want to understand Jonah rightly, we should listen to Jesus’ commentary on Jonah. Jesus refers to the sign of Jonah when confronting a generation that demands signs but refuses to repent. In Matthew, Jesus connects Jonah’s time in the fish with the Son of Man being in the heart of the earth. Luke does not include that specific detail, which helps us see that the sign of Jonah is larger than the fish-to-tomb comparison. In both Matthew and Luke, Jesus highlights the repentance of Nineveh. The men of Nineveh will rise in judgment against those who reject the greater one who has come. This means the sign of Jonah is bound up with the gospel. The greater prophet has come. He dies and rises. Repentance and forgiveness are proclaimed in his name. The proper response is not curiosity but repentance and faith.

Jonah preached judgment to Nineveh, and they repented. Jesus is greater than Jonah, and many still refuse him. That should sober us.

This sermon gives a clear opportunity to preach Christ. Jonah’s sin was not swept under the rug. Nineveh’s sin was not ignored. God forgives sinners because sin is finally dealt with at the cross. We look back to what Jonah could only look forward to in shadow. Jesus bears the guilt of his people and gives them his righteousness.

Sermon 4: Jesus, Jonah, and the Storm

Text: Matthew 8:23-27, Mark 4:35-41, or Luke 8:22-25
Main idea: The Lord who ruled the storm in Jonah is revealed in Jesus Christ, who rules creation and saves his people.

The Gospel accounts of Jesus calming the storm allude to Jonah 1 in striking ways. There is a boat. There is a dangerous storm. There are terrified men who think they may perish. There is someone asleep in the boat. There is fear. There is a question about divine concern and power. There is deliverance from death. There is amazement and worshipful fear when the wind and sea obey. In Jonah, the sailors call upon Jonah to call upon his God so perhaps they will not perish. The wind and sea obey the Lord. When the sea ceases from its raging, the sailors fear the Lord exceedingly and offer sacrifice. In the Gospel storm accounts, the disciples fear they will perish. In Mark, they ask Jesus, “Teacher, do you not care that we are perishing?” That question echoes the concern at the heart of Jonah 4, where Jonah does not care for Nineveh as God does. Jesus then rebukes the wind and sea, and they obey him. The disciples are filled with fear and ask who this is, that even wind and sea obey him.

Jonah helps us answer the disciples’ question. If the Lord commands the wind and waves in Jonah, and the wind and waves obey Jesus in the Gospels, then much is being said about Jesus. The God of Jonah is standing in the boat. But Jesus is not merely another Jonah. He is greater than Jonah. Jonah sleeps in disobedience. Jesus sleeps in perfect trust. Jonah is thrown into the sea because of his own sin. Jesus goes into death because of ours. Jonah cannot command the storm. Jesus rebukes the wind and sea, and they obey. Jonah is the prophet running from God’s mission to the nations. Jesus is the Son sent by the Father to save sinners from every nation.

This sermon brings the series to the person of Christ. Jesus is the obedient Son, the Lord of creation, the greater prophet, and the Savior who enters judgment to rescue his people.

Gospel Connections in Jonah

Jonah gives many faithful paths to Christ. Jesus himself appeals to Jonah. That should give preachers confidence to connect Jonah to Christ, but it should also keep us from creative nonsense. We do not need to invent a secret meaning for every wave, plank, and fishbone. Jesus gives us the main road.

Jonah’s three days point to Christ’s death and resurrection. Jonah’s deliverance from the fish points beyond itself to the greater deliverance accomplished by Jesus. Jonah’s preaching to Nineveh points to the greater prophet whose message demands repentance. Nineveh’s repentance exposes the guilt of those who reject Christ. Jonah’s confession that salvation belongs to the Lord is fulfilled in the saving work of Jesus.

Jonah also shows why the gospel is necessary. Jonah sins. The sailors need mercy. Nineveh deserves judgment. None of them can save themselves. God must provide salvation.

The sailors are worried about innocent blood, but Jonah is not finally innocent. The Ninevites are not innocent. We are not innocent. The only truly innocent one is Jesus Christ. He is the one whose blood saves the guilty.

Helps for Preachers and Teachers

Start by reading Jonah as a whole. It is short enough to read in one sitting, and it should be read that way several times. The book’s repetition, irony, and structure become clearer when read as a complete narrative.

Do not make the fish the center. The fish is important because God appoints it and Jesus references Jonah’s time in it. But the fish is not the point. God is the point. God’s mercy is the point. Jonah’s heart is the problem. Salvation belongs to the Lord.

Do not flatten Jonah into a children’s story. Children should learn Jonah, but adults should not read it as if it were only about obeying God so you do not get swallowed by consequences. That application is not entirely wrong, but it is thin.

Do not make Jonah a hero too quickly. Jonah is a prophet, and he eventually obeys outwardly, but the book keeps pressing into his heart. The reader should feel the discomfort of seeing Jonah’s resistance and recognizing it.

Do not miss the nations. God cares about the sailors. God cares about Nineveh. God cares about people Jonah does not care about. The book rebukes small-hearted religion that enjoys mercy privately while begrudging it publicly.

Do not preach grace as if repentance is optional. Nineveh repents. Jonah must repent. Grace does not excuse rebellion. Grace overcomes it.

Questions for Personal Study

As you read Jonah, ask these questions:

  1. Where does Jonah resist the word of the Lord?

  2. Who obeys God in this passage, and who does not?

  3. How does God show sovereignty over creation and people?

  4. How do the non-Israelites respond?

  5. How does God show mercy to Jonah?

  6. How does God show mercy to people Jonah does not love?

  7. What does Jonah believe about God, and where does he struggle to trust what he knows?

  8. How does this passage point to Christ?

  9. What response is the book pressing upon me?

The last question may be the most important. Jonah ends with a question because the book is not content to leave us as observers. It drags us into the courtroom.

Getting Started

To get started in Jonah, do not start with the fish. Start with the structure. Read the book as two mirrored narratives. Watch how the first half teaches you to read the second half. Notice the irony that everyone seems to obey except Jonah. Listen to Jonah’s confession that salvation belongs to the Lord. Then let the unresolved ending do its work.

It may be valuable to preach or teach Jonah first as a complete unit, drawing on the connections between the two narratives. Then, to solidify the themes, look at the New Testament passages through the lens of Jonah. Jesus’ teaching on the sign of Jonah and the Gospel accounts of Jesus calming the storm help us see how Jonah points forward to Christ.

Jonah is not merely about a prophet who ran. It is about a God who pursues. It is not merely about Nineveh’s repentance. It is about God’s mercy to sinners and his patience with a prophet who should know better. It is not merely about ancient history. It is about our hearts when God’s grace goes places we would not have sent it.

And ultimately, Jonah points us to Jesus Christ. Jesus is the greater prophet, the true sign, the perfectly obedient Son, the one with innocent blood, the Lord of the storm, and the Savior of sinners. Salvation belongs to the Lord. That is where Jonah takes us. That is where every faithful sermon on Jonah should eventually land.